Now that the television season is over and the upfronts are finished we know the ultimate fates of some of our favorite shows. What’s surprising this year is the amount of on-the-bubble shows that will be returning next fall for a repeat performance. Some of these shows were saved by passionate fans and some were saved in spite of ardent detractors. But in some ways all of the following shows were unlikely renewals.
Grimm
The supernatural fairy tale caper initially didn’t seem to have a chance. First, the market looked to be saturated with fairy tale fare this season, especially ratings hit Once Upon A Time. Then the show, led by cult veteran and former Angel scribe David Greenwalt, ended up in the Friday death slot. Clearly, NBC wasn’t showing a lot of confidence in the freshmen series. Yet somehow, against all odds, Grimm actually did well in its Friday slot of doom. So next season Grimm will return to solve more fairytale mysteries, like the case of the show that survived despite unlikely odds.
Fringe
Fringe really owes its survival to the supernatural show’s dedicated band of followers. The show’s twisty fourth season got even more complex, making it basically impossible for the show to attract new fans. The Friday night death slot FOX sent the show to certainly didn’t help. Perhaps FOX, having been burned by cancelling multiple cult classics (Firefly and Arrested Development come instantly to mind) just got cancellation cold feet? Or maybe it was the siren lure of 100 syndication-worthy episodes? Whatever the reason, the Fringe team will return next fall for a shortened fifth and last season.
Ask any critic and most would shake their heads that the critically reviled Whitney got a second lease at life. The show was never a ratings hit, pulling down only modest numbers in its initial Thursday night slot. Of the two shows with star Whitney Cummings’ name on the marque, it was nowhere near CBS hit 2 Broke Girls. NBC tried the show on a less competitive night for comedies, Wednesday, with little more luck. Most saw Whitney as an inevitable contender for the cancellation pile and were shocked at the show’s renewal. Sure, the show will be returning in the Friday time slot of zero confidence, but most didn’t expect it to return at all.
The Kate Walsh medical drama from executive producer Shonda Rhimes seemed likely to be on its way out. Never having captured the buzz of mothership show Grey’s Anatomy, Private Practice has nevertheless been a decent performer for ABC. But the show’s modest ratings and lack of buzz seemed to finally be catching up with it. Plus, going into its sixth season the show seemed a bit long in the tooth. However, ABC, perhaps to keep up relations with mega-producer Rhimes, decided to give the show another season. So expect Addison back on your screens this coming fall.
You know you love Gossip Girl but the ratings have not loved the formerly buzzy Upper East Side drama. This is no shock, despite getting tons of ink and holding down hot starlets, Gossip Girl has never been a ratings bonanza. Perhaps this is because the show operated on the modest CW network or perhaps it’s because its younger-skewing audience was watching in different ways. This season, however, tested even the low bar set for the scandalous show. Maybe it was the storylines (Dan and Blair? Really?) or maybe it was the age of the show, but this season’s ratings were not exactly gossip worthy. With one season left on the contracts of all the major cast members, however, The CW decided to give the show a final season of 10 or 11 episodes to bid farewell to the Upper East Side.
CSI New York was never quite the powerhouse of the original flavor CSI franchise. With CBS beginning to dump some of the older crime procedurals from its slate, this big apple edition seemed destined for the chopping block. Indeed, one of the CSI franchises did fall this season; it just wasn’t the big city version. CBS cancelled David Caruso’s CSI Miami, making 2012 the last year for us to watch him take off his signature shades. In a surprise turn, however, the eye network decided to keep around CSI New York.
Most didn’t expect the Kiefer Sutherland drama Touch to make it to the renewal pile. Despite literally months of buildup the show disappointed in the ratings when it actually arrived. Further, it wasn’t all that critically loved and didn’t lead to the kind of watercooler moments the network hoped for. It’ s a good bet, however, that after the long-running 24 FOX would like to stay in the Sutherland business. So Touch will return for a second season, with the network hoping that the father and autistic child drama will pull down more viewers.
Community
Six seasons and a movie were always a bit of a pipe-dream for the critically loved, little watched Community. While the meta sitcom about a strange study group at an even stranger community college went to weird and often great heights this season, the ratings never materialized. After a fall run, NBC abruptly yanked the show off its schedule. That was bad news for anyone who has watched a beloved and low-rated gem on the way to cancellation before. Fans rallied around the show, staging literal protests outside NBC and starting Twitter campaigns. All the campaigning worked…sort of. Community will be back in the fall for an initial 13 episode order. That’s the good news. The bad news? The sitcom will be airing with Whitney on Fridays and mad genius creator Dan Harmon has been fired and replaced with two new show runners. Community might carry on, but it certainly won’t be the show that fans and critics fought to save.
—Read the full article and sound off in the comments at RoadRunner.com HERE!!









